With the paucity of SAFA’s own youth development programmes coupled with your inability to develop and implement a coherent strategy in that regard, it really boggles the mind that you should be taking such a draconian stance against an initiative that can only benefit you as an organisation and South African football as a whole. To put things in perspective, I’d like to emphasise the importance of compliance with stated rules by reiterating that as long as all the players participating in the Diski Challenge fulfill the requirements of being defined as professional players you have no business interfering with what the League is trying to do. It is their constitutional prerogative to establish and operate such a competition.Furthermore, you know very well that you are under pressure from CAF and FIFA to implement the Club Licensing Programme. Under that programme there are certain non-negotiable deliverables that clubs must fulfill in order for you to grant them their annual licence to register with the relevant league. One of those non-negotiable deliverables is youth development. In order for you to grant the licence each club must prove that it has proper youth development structures. Not just one age group but several tiers of youth development, at least two of which shall be compulsory, U17 and U19. Part of that development surely has to be the creation of opportunities for them to play competitive football. It cannot just be training and coaching to the exclusion of participating in a competitive league.If clubs are soon to be compelled to DEVELOP YOUTH, what's wrong with them pre-empting the process by starting now before it becomes compulsory? If you are saying they are overstepping their mandate now, what will you say when you are forced by FIFA to compel clubs to have youth development structures? I hope that your counter-argument will not be that they must "develop" them but cannot make them play in any organised league against their age mates? That would really be ludicrous!I think you are wrong by creating this "damned if I do, damned if I don't" situation, which is exactly what it will be when the time comes for club licencing to be compulsory. It is my contention that the development of young footballers should never be used as a pawn in the political chess games that we have seen being played out in South African football. The future of the country's football is much more important than personal egos. The nation, not individuals, owns the beautiful sport. I can bet my last cent that if we were to conduct a referendum today there would be only one result, a resounding YES to the NSL-Multichoice U19 League in its original planned format not this watered down Reserve League that you insist on.The news that you have secured sponsorship for U19 and U17 leagues is wonderful news for South African football. From what I was able to gather with regards to that, the leagues will be under you. That's great. But it also tells me that they will be leagues for amateur players and must rightfully be administered by you. Amateur football is your domain and responsibility. Will your U19 work at cross-purposes with the NSL's U19 League of professionals? Not at all! There are thousands, probably millions, of U19 players not signed by any professional club. They are not earning any excess income and therefore their status is amateur. The fact that they are amateur does not necessarily translate to them being poor performers than those within club structures. The fact of the matter is that clubs operate within very tight budgets and obviously cannot contract and pay all players out there. Supply always outstrips demand. If you want to use only those players contracted to professional clubs in your mooted U19 and U17, then you are effectively meting out double jeopardy to your very own amateurs. They cannot get into the clubs and now you want to shut them out of their own league? How fair is that? Who benefits from such an exclusionist arrangement?Can you imagine how fast tracked development can be if you had your amateur U19 league and the NSL runs its own U19 for professional players contracted to its member clubs? Does that not widen opportunities? Is the end product not the creation of the widest pool of players from which your national teams will draw players? I think you are wrong in preventing the League from running its own U19 league for professional players. Do the right thing, beloved father.Have you forgotten how far down we have slid on the FIFA rankings? Have you forgotten that the primary reason for that is not only the paucity in the capacity and quality of our youth development programmes - because the professional clubs have been doing that that for you through their own youth structures - it is rather the lack of regular competitive football for them to hone their skills? Who will be the ultimate beneficiary of a professional U19 League if not the same national team that is your pride and joy? How can you then justify stopping a project that will produce talent to take this country's football forward? How do you expect this decision to find favour with the spiritual owners of the game, the football-loving masses of our people?We have all seen your national team coaches carrying clipboards and frantically taking down notes at PSL games. Evidently they scout for players from those who are already playing for their clubs. Consider this: Club owners are business people. They want returns on their investment. They want to win the league and cup competitions. They may be passionate about the game but they are still driven by the profit motive just like other entrepreneurs in the corporate world. In order to achieve their objectives they hire coaches. Any coach who does not deliver is fired. Can you then blame coaches for not promoting any young talent from their own clubs' development structures but rather buy proven professionals? Who in their right mind would gamble his job on some untested youngster? This creates a solid ceiling for young professionals. They have to be exceptional special gems in order to be seen and given a berth in the senior team. At best, they have to hope for a club with limited resources to buy them and give them exposure. Only then can they be seen by the national coaches. Does that not have the effect of delaying the process of unearthing talent? Why, father, why?Does it not also drastically reduce the pool of players that the national coaches can assess and select? It does! Are you still wondering why we are ranked much lower than we should, given the massive financial resources we have compared to many of the countries above us on the CAF and FIFA rankings? On these bases, how do you justify interfering with this project? Is it your objective to perpetuate this heart-breaking failure to make a mark on the world stage? I know for a fact that you are wrong. And I hope you will urgently review your decision to interfere.I am writing this letter as your son, a loving, respectful and grateful son. I am grateful for all the things you have done for me. The first time I boarded an airplane, you had made that possible. The first time my name appeared on a newspaper page was thanks to you. The first time my ugly face, perched on a starved body, appeared on television was thanks to none other than you. The first time I crossed the borders of this country - uhm, legally with a passport, not on foot - you had made that possible. Were it not for you, I would still be an unknown rural boy like many of my peers in the village of Nqadu. And for all that, I am eternally grateful. But my being grateful cannot be reason enough for me to keep quiet when I think you are wrong. On the contrary, it is because of my love and respect for you and as a long-standing member of your family that I am voicing my concern on this matter and airing my belief that you are making a very critical error of judgment. Believe me father, there is nothing more gracious than admitting an error, remedying it and allowing history and the football gods to forever judge you favourably. Do the right thing. Do it even if it means "losing face". Rather lose face for doing the right thing than obstinately forge ahead with a course of action that has a detrimental impact on the very game that you are working hard to rebuild to claim its righful place at the highest pedestal amongst the top nations in the world.I claim your fatherhood as one of the youngest persons in this country to establish a football club. I was a mere 14-year old teenager when I started my own club and vowed to help establish a proper football league in my area instead of adding to the many clubs that played only friendlies and rural tournaments with pigs, goats and sheep as prizes. I consider myself your child for having been a secretary of a local football association at that tender age of 14. Although you were never there to teach me how to play, how to coach, how to referee and how to be a good administrator, I still learnt on my own. Through trial and error I acquired knowledge. I forgave you because it was not easy for you to do all those things as a football father operating in an apartheid state.I knew that you could not do the developmental intervention that a caring football father should do because of various factors which were not of your own making. In appreciation of that hard cold fact, I and many other club owners, continued to toil under the heavy burden. You could not be there when I paid money collected over many moons from meagre pocket money to have a bulldozer excavating out the boulders from the only piece of land the local chief granted permission for my club to utilize as a football field. I understood your absence when we used hands, shovels and wheelbarrows to fill up the holes where the boulders had been dug. I accepted your inability to help when I used a borrowed axe to chop down six trees from which four uprights and two crossbars were fashioned to make goal posts. I did not even cry out to you when I needed to buy packets of lime to throw in powder form on the ground to mark the field. I never lamented your absence for those long hours when I and my boys used hand sickles to cut the grass every other week. I never complained about your lack of assistance when after every rainy season we had to deal with a multitude of mole hills that sprang up on our pitch. I understood and continued to love you. I continue to love you but I think you are wrong.Having started playing football at age 6 on dusty make-shift pitches in the rural areas of the then Transkei homeland, I now lay claim to more than 40 years of unbroken involvement in football. Apart from my brief sojourn into professional football administration, I have always been, and still regard myself as, part of your family. You gave me a platform to express myself in a way that very few poor kids like me in rural areas will ever get to enjoy. I repaid you with honesty, loyalty and integrity. I became a worthy ambassador representing the best that your family can be, both nationally and internationally. I have now completed the Perfect 5 - playing, coaching, refereeing, administration and broadcasting - and I know of no other person in the whole world who has had the pleasure of serving the game in all 5 spheres. Thank you for making that possible. But, all of that said, I cannot keep quiet and pretend to be happy when I am not. I know you mean well and you want to protect the constitutional integrity of the family but that cannot be done through a flagrant disregard of the provisions of the same constitution that you purport to honour and uphold. I do understand that you need to reassert the position of the family as the supreme custodian of football in the country but that cannot be achieved with regressive, myopic decisions. I accept the need to always remind the League that it is "surbodinate to SAFA" as espoused in your Constitution but that should never be done at the expense of progress.You have gone through a very trying period which led to sponsors withdrawing their financial support and those remaining drastically scaling down their contributions. You changed your leadership and there are signs that things can get better. Sponsors are beginning to believe in the value of supporting football and are willing to invest commensurate financial value for the mileage they can reap from their partnership with the sport. It will certainly be foolhardy for you to act in a manner that suggests you’d rather cock-a-snook at a company that is by far the biggest investor this country’s football has ever had for reasons that defy every fathomable percept of logic. Even though Multichoice is not one of your own direct sponsors, the billions they pay to your Special Member, the professional league, gives a fillip to the development of the game’s standard at the professional level, meaning that the national teams also benefit from such elevated levels of performances by eligible players. This implies that as SAFA, you derive a direct benefit from this indirect financial support, a compelling reason for you to be a supportive stakeholder in the value-laden relationship that Multichoice enjoys with your most valued affiliate. That relationship makes your League, yes YOUR League father, look really good - the best on the continent and Top 10 in the world. That should make you a proud father. When a child of the family makes strides is it not the entire family that gleans glory? Doesn't a major portion of that glory accrue to the father who gave birth to that child? Why should a proud father feel the need to compete with his own son yet all due credit goes to the family as a whole? I think you are wrong father. Father, I am begging you on behalf of all the young professionals who had hopes of finally getting long-awaited exposure. With your insistence that the league should merely be a reserve league for out-of-form and injured players of whatever age robs them of this glorious opportunity to showcase their talent against professionals of the same age from other clubs. I beg you to reconsider your decision because it is constitutionally wrong. I beg you to allow the league as originally planned because it is simply good for the country. I do not carry anyone's brief. In the past I have spoken my mind about things that I felt the NSL was not doing right. I was neither doing that at your behest nor on your behalf. Hence, I am not in the least worried that I may be accused of speaking for and on behalf of the NSL. In fact, seeing how the League meekly capitulated at your onslought, I suspect that it might not be happy as well with me writing this letter and push this into the public discourse when they had already resigned themselves to the fate you have forced upon them. Finally, please forgive me for making this letter public. I know that you raised me under a doctrine that family dirty linen should not be hung in public but I am a child of this family and I have seen how the carpet at our home has grown heavier and heavier. I was scared that it might somehow cover my plea and prevent it from reaching your ears. If, by writing this letter and availing it to the public with the sole objective being to stimulate debate on the matter, you feel I have disrespected you, I am sorry. I'd rather present myself for your admonishing than to keep quiet when I feel the need to talk.Your loving sonAce Ncobo - writing in his personal capacity
OPEN LETTER TO SAFA by Ace Ncobo
With the paucity of SAFA’s own youth development programmes coupled with your inability to develop and implement a coherent strategy in that regard, it really boggles the mind that you should be taking such a draconian stance against an initiative that can only benefit you as an organisation and South African football as a whole. To put things in perspective, I’d like to emphasise the importance of compliance with stated rules by reiterating that as long as all the players participating in the Diski Challenge fulfill the requirements of being defined as professional players you have no business interfering with what the League is trying to do. It is their constitutional prerogative to establish and operate such a competition.Furthermore, you know very well that you are under pressure from CAF and FIFA to implement the Club Licensing Programme. Under that programme there are certain non-negotiable deliverables that clubs must fulfill in order for you to grant them their annual licence to register with the relevant league. One of those non-negotiable deliverables is youth development. In order for you to grant the licence each club must prove that it has proper youth development structures. Not just one age group but several tiers of youth development, at least two of which shall be compulsory, U17 and U19. Part of that development surely has to be the creation of opportunities for them to play competitive football. It cannot just be training and coaching to the exclusion of participating in a competitive league.If clubs are soon to be compelled to DEVELOP YOUTH, what's wrong with them pre-empting the process by starting now before it becomes compulsory? If you are saying they are overstepping their mandate now, what will you say when you are forced by FIFA to compel clubs to have youth development structures? I hope that your counter-argument will not be that they must "develop" them but cannot make them play in any organised league against their age mates? That would really be ludicrous!I think you are wrong by creating this "damned if I do, damned if I don't" situation, which is exactly what it will be when the time comes for club licencing to be compulsory. It is my contention that the development of young footballers should never be used as a pawn in the political chess games that we have seen being played out in South African football. The future of the country's football is much more important than personal egos. The nation, not individuals, owns the beautiful sport. I can bet my last cent that if we were to conduct a referendum today there would be only one result, a resounding YES to the NSL-Multichoice U19 League in its original planned format not this watered down Reserve League that you insist on.The news that you have secured sponsorship for U19 and U17 leagues is wonderful news for South African football. From what I was able to gather with regards to that, the leagues will be under you. That's great. But it also tells me that they will be leagues for amateur players and must rightfully be administered by you. Amateur football is your domain and responsibility. Will your U19 work at cross-purposes with the NSL's U19 League of professionals? Not at all! There are thousands, probably millions, of U19 players not signed by any professional club. They are not earning any excess income and therefore their status is amateur. The fact that they are amateur does not necessarily translate to them being poor performers than those within club structures. The fact of the matter is that clubs operate within very tight budgets and obviously cannot contract and pay all players out there. Supply always outstrips demand. If you want to use only those players contracted to professional clubs in your mooted U19 and U17, then you are effectively meting out double jeopardy to your very own amateurs. They cannot get into the clubs and now you want to shut them out of their own league? How fair is that? Who benefits from such an exclusionist arrangement?Can you imagine how fast tracked development can be if you had your amateur U19 league and the NSL runs its own U19 for professional players contracted to its member clubs? Does that not widen opportunities? Is the end product not the creation of the widest pool of players from which your national teams will draw players? I think you are wrong in preventing the League from running its own U19 league for professional players. Do the right thing, beloved father.Have you forgotten how far down we have slid on the FIFA rankings? Have you forgotten that the primary reason for that is not only the paucity in the capacity and quality of our youth development programmes - because the professional clubs have been doing that that for you through their own youth structures - it is rather the lack of regular competitive football for them to hone their skills? Who will be the ultimate beneficiary of a professional U19 League if not the same national team that is your pride and joy? How can you then justify stopping a project that will produce talent to take this country's football forward? How do you expect this decision to find favour with the spiritual owners of the game, the football-loving masses of our people?We have all seen your national team coaches carrying clipboards and frantically taking down notes at PSL games. Evidently they scout for players from those who are already playing for their clubs. Consider this: Club owners are business people. They want returns on their investment. They want to win the league and cup competitions. They may be passionate about the game but they are still driven by the profit motive just like other entrepreneurs in the corporate world. In order to achieve their objectives they hire coaches. Any coach who does not deliver is fired. Can you then blame coaches for not promoting any young talent from their own clubs' development structures but rather buy proven professionals? Who in their right mind would gamble his job on some untested youngster? This creates a solid ceiling for young professionals. They have to be exceptional special gems in order to be seen and given a berth in the senior team. At best, they have to hope for a club with limited resources to buy them and give them exposure. Only then can they be seen by the national coaches. Does that not have the effect of delaying the process of unearthing talent? Why, father, why?Does it not also drastically reduce the pool of players that the national coaches can assess and select? It does! Are you still wondering why we are ranked much lower than we should, given the massive financial resources we have compared to many of the countries above us on the CAF and FIFA rankings? On these bases, how do you justify interfering with this project? Is it your objective to perpetuate this heart-breaking failure to make a mark on the world stage? I know for a fact that you are wrong. And I hope you will urgently review your decision to interfere.I am writing this letter as your son, a loving, respectful and grateful son. I am grateful for all the things you have done for me. The first time I boarded an airplane, you had made that possible. The first time my name appeared on a newspaper page was thanks to you. The first time my ugly face, perched on a starved body, appeared on television was thanks to none other than you. The first time I crossed the borders of this country - uhm, legally with a passport, not on foot - you had made that possible. Were it not for you, I would still be an unknown rural boy like many of my peers in the village of Nqadu. And for all that, I am eternally grateful. But my being grateful cannot be reason enough for me to keep quiet when I think you are wrong. On the contrary, it is because of my love and respect for you and as a long-standing member of your family that I am voicing my concern on this matter and airing my belief that you are making a very critical error of judgment. Believe me father, there is nothing more gracious than admitting an error, remedying it and allowing history and the football gods to forever judge you favourably. Do the right thing. Do it even if it means "losing face". Rather lose face for doing the right thing than obstinately forge ahead with a course of action that has a detrimental impact on the very game that you are working hard to rebuild to claim its righful place at the highest pedestal amongst the top nations in the world.I claim your fatherhood as one of the youngest persons in this country to establish a football club. I was a mere 14-year old teenager when I started my own club and vowed to help establish a proper football league in my area instead of adding to the many clubs that played only friendlies and rural tournaments with pigs, goats and sheep as prizes. I consider myself your child for having been a secretary of a local football association at that tender age of 14. Although you were never there to teach me how to play, how to coach, how to referee and how to be a good administrator, I still learnt on my own. Through trial and error I acquired knowledge. I forgave you because it was not easy for you to do all those things as a football father operating in an apartheid state.I knew that you could not do the developmental intervention that a caring football father should do because of various factors which were not of your own making. In appreciation of that hard cold fact, I and many other club owners, continued to toil under the heavy burden. You could not be there when I paid money collected over many moons from meagre pocket money to have a bulldozer excavating out the boulders from the only piece of land the local chief granted permission for my club to utilize as a football field. I understood your absence when we used hands, shovels and wheelbarrows to fill up the holes where the boulders had been dug. I accepted your inability to help when I used a borrowed axe to chop down six trees from which four uprights and two crossbars were fashioned to make goal posts. I did not even cry out to you when I needed to buy packets of lime to throw in powder form on the ground to mark the field. I never lamented your absence for those long hours when I and my boys used hand sickles to cut the grass every other week. I never complained about your lack of assistance when after every rainy season we had to deal with a multitude of mole hills that sprang up on our pitch. I understood and continued to love you. I continue to love you but I think you are wrong.Having started playing football at age 6 on dusty make-shift pitches in the rural areas of the then Transkei homeland, I now lay claim to more than 40 years of unbroken involvement in football. Apart from my brief sojourn into professional football administration, I have always been, and still regard myself as, part of your family. You gave me a platform to express myself in a way that very few poor kids like me in rural areas will ever get to enjoy. I repaid you with honesty, loyalty and integrity. I became a worthy ambassador representing the best that your family can be, both nationally and internationally. I have now completed the Perfect 5 - playing, coaching, refereeing, administration and broadcasting - and I know of no other person in the whole world who has had the pleasure of serving the game in all 5 spheres. Thank you for making that possible. But, all of that said, I cannot keep quiet and pretend to be happy when I am not. I know you mean well and you want to protect the constitutional integrity of the family but that cannot be done through a flagrant disregard of the provisions of the same constitution that you purport to honour and uphold. I do understand that you need to reassert the position of the family as the supreme custodian of football in the country but that cannot be achieved with regressive, myopic decisions. I accept the need to always remind the League that it is "surbodinate to SAFA" as espoused in your Constitution but that should never be done at the expense of progress.You have gone through a very trying period which led to sponsors withdrawing their financial support and those remaining drastically scaling down their contributions. You changed your leadership and there are signs that things can get better. Sponsors are beginning to believe in the value of supporting football and are willing to invest commensurate financial value for the mileage they can reap from their partnership with the sport. It will certainly be foolhardy for you to act in a manner that suggests you’d rather cock-a-snook at a company that is by far the biggest investor this country’s football has ever had for reasons that defy every fathomable percept of logic. Even though Multichoice is not one of your own direct sponsors, the billions they pay to your Special Member, the professional league, gives a fillip to the development of the game’s standard at the professional level, meaning that the national teams also benefit from such elevated levels of performances by eligible players. This implies that as SAFA, you derive a direct benefit from this indirect financial support, a compelling reason for you to be a supportive stakeholder in the value-laden relationship that Multichoice enjoys with your most valued affiliate. That relationship makes your League, yes YOUR League father, look really good - the best on the continent and Top 10 in the world. That should make you a proud father. When a child of the family makes strides is it not the entire family that gleans glory? Doesn't a major portion of that glory accrue to the father who gave birth to that child? Why should a proud father feel the need to compete with his own son yet all due credit goes to the family as a whole? I think you are wrong father. Father, I am begging you on behalf of all the young professionals who had hopes of finally getting long-awaited exposure. With your insistence that the league should merely be a reserve league for out-of-form and injured players of whatever age robs them of this glorious opportunity to showcase their talent against professionals of the same age from other clubs. I beg you to reconsider your decision because it is constitutionally wrong. I beg you to allow the league as originally planned because it is simply good for the country. I do not carry anyone's brief. In the past I have spoken my mind about things that I felt the NSL was not doing right. I was neither doing that at your behest nor on your behalf. Hence, I am not in the least worried that I may be accused of speaking for and on behalf of the NSL. In fact, seeing how the League meekly capitulated at your onslought, I suspect that it might not be happy as well with me writing this letter and push this into the public discourse when they had already resigned themselves to the fate you have forced upon them. Finally, please forgive me for making this letter public. I know that you raised me under a doctrine that family dirty linen should not be hung in public but I am a child of this family and I have seen how the carpet at our home has grown heavier and heavier. I was scared that it might somehow cover my plea and prevent it from reaching your ears. If, by writing this letter and availing it to the public with the sole objective being to stimulate debate on the matter, you feel I have disrespected you, I am sorry. I'd rather present myself for your admonishing than to keep quiet when I feel the need to talk.Your loving sonAce Ncobo - writing in his personal capacity