Obama takes tougher line against Gaza deaths

Washington - The Obama administration condemned the deadly shelling of a United Nations school in Gaza on Wednesday, using tough, yet carefully worded language that reflects growing White House irritation with Israel and the mounting civilian casualties stemming from its ground and air war against Hamas.

The US frustrations were compounded by a flurry of Israeli media reports this week that appeared aimed at discrediting President Barack Obama and Secretary of State John Kerry, who spent days trying to negotiate an unsuccessful cease-fire between Israel and Hamas.

In unusually blunt language, a state department spokesperson on Wednesday repeatedly described one of the reports as "complete crap".

The developments injected fresh tension into the often fraught relationship between Obama and the Israeli government, while also highlighting the president's willingness to take a tougher line against the long-time US ally than some of his predecessors or lawmakers on Capitol Hill.

While Obama and other top officials consistently state their support for Israel's right to defend itself against Hamas rocket fire, the White House has been making increasingly strong statements about the Palestinian civilians dying in Israeli attacks.

Officials have also directly called on Israel to do more to prevent the casualties.


More than 1 300 Palestinians have been killed in three weeks of fighting, according to the Hamas-run Gaza health ministry. More than 50 Israelis have also died in the clashes.

The White House escalated its rhetoric yet again on Wednesday by condemning the shelling of the UN school that was sheltering displaced Palestinians.

While the administration did not publicly assign blame for the attack, UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said "all available evidence" pointed to Israel and the Israeli military acknowledged that it fired back after its soldiers were targeted by mortar rounds launched from the vicinity of the school.

"We are extremely concerned that thousands of internally displaced Palestinians who have been called on by the Israeli military to evacuate their homes are not safe in UN designated shelters in Gaza," said Bernadette Meehan, a spokeswoman for the White House's National Security Council.

She also condemned "those responsible for hiding weapons in the United Nations facilities in Gaza", a nod to Israel's charge that Hamas is housing arms in those facilities.

Obama has had an up-and-down relationship with Israel from the start of his presidency. Israeli officials balked at what they saw as overly harsh criticism of their settlement policy and have been deeply skeptical of Obama's efforts to negotiate a nuclear agreement with Iran.

Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu also have struggled to develop a rapport, with the Israeli leader at one point lecturing his US counterpart in the Oval Office in front of reporters, photographers and television cameras.

Israel's demands

Yet their relationship appeared to be on the upswing last year when Obama made his first visit to Israel as president.

The trip was well-received in Israel and the resumption of U.S.-led peace talks between the Israelis and Palestinians quickly followed.

But those talks collapsed earlier this year amid US frustration with both sides of the intractable conflict. The current bout of violence quickly followed, sparked by the deaths of three Israeli teenagers in the West Bank.

Kerry, who expended a significant amount of personal capital on the peace talks, has also stepped in to try to orchestrate a cease-fire between Israel and Hamas. Yet his efforts failed to make any progress and his departure from the region last weekend was accompanied by stringing criticism in Israeli media reports.

Ari Shavit, a columnist for Israel's leading liberal newspaper Haaretz, said Kerry put a proposal on the table that amounted to a "strategic terrorist attack".

Others accused Kerry of aligning himself too closely with Hamas and being dismissive of Israel's demands.

On Tuesday, an Israeli media report appeared to cast Obama in the same light with the release of what was alleged to be a transcript of Obama's weekend call with Netanyahu.

Both the Israeli government and the Obama administration vigorously denied the authenticity of the transcript.

"It's complete crap", state department spokesperson Marie Harf said on Wednesday. She sidestepped questions about who the US held responsible for the reports, but said it was clear that the intention is to hurt the US-Israeli relationship.

"I don't know toward what end. I don't know who did it", she said. "But I don't know what other conclusion you can draw from that."

The administration's charged language is in contrast to the posture from Democrats and Republicans on Capitol Hill, who are pressing the White House to take no action that pressures Israel to halt its military operations. Lawmakers are also seeking to push through a $225m missile defence package for Israel.

Even as the White House raises concerns about the civilian casualties, the administration is helping Israel resupply its ammunition stockpiles.

A defence official said the US offered to provide mortar rounds and grenades from a depot it maintains in Israel as part of a routine effort to use up older stock and replace what is there with newer ammunition.

Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel spoke with his Israeli counterpart, Moshe Yaalon, about the Gaza crisis on Wednesday. Hagel's spokesperson, Navy Rear Admiral John Kirby, said Yaalon thanked Hagel for US financial support for Israel's Iron Dome anti-rocket defence system, and Hagel reiterated US concern about the rising number of Palestinian civilian deaths in Gaza.

- AP
DerekMain 2014-07-31 10:52:51 AM
Smoke & mirrors - why give Israel more ammunition then? The US is complicit in the war crimes.
Mathaithai 2014-07-31 10:55:36 AM
These are hypocrites. This is just a smoke-screen, while arming Israel. This is a shame. The poor Gaza people cannot leave Gaza as all borders are closed around them by Israel and Egypt. This is heart-breaking!!!!!!!!!!!!
Louie Walshe 2014-07-31 11:03:27 AM
US double standards. Condemn the Israeli offensive on Gaza by restocking Israel's ammunition supply. That makes sense. Condemn Russia for its involvement in Ukraine but it's perfectly ok for the US to stick its own fingers in everyone else's pie. Everyone must obey international law or the US will impose sanctions or provide the bombs for your head.
William Stokes 2014-07-31 11:04:13 AM
The Jews were given the option of moving to Uganda or Palestine. When they moved to Palestine en masse, the Palestinians were there already. They defended their right to Palestine. Then came the Jews with growing support from USA who fought the Cold war at the time. Even Iran, Turkey and Ethiopia traded secretly with Israel. Israel's policy of periphery. Now we have the massacre.
Nawhal Umm Fiyaaz Majiet-Armien 2014-07-31 11:05:09 AM
i thought Obama would be america's savior, what a shame he turned out like this
Tshephangsithole 2014-07-31 11:10:59 AM
American snake, this idiots get in all affairs and yet blame Russia on its own affairs. How can they condemn everything happening there but still arm Israel
Joy Thorpe 2014-07-31 11:14:11 AM
Obama is playing both sides of the fence ! The US has just re-armed the Israel!
Charlie Mdletshe 2014-07-31 11:31:25 AM
talk,talk and talk, he will take no action whatsoever
Mashooda Dhorat 2014-07-31 11:33:18 AM
obama is saving his own ass. His silence is because he knows that netanyhoooo will tell him to go to hell and look forward to the trip. That is why he is silent. He is also afraid of being imminently impeached and any utterance against his baas in tel aviv will finalise the process, so he is shutting his trap. So is his wife who i admired when she stood up for the kidnapped girls by taking a public stance by launching the #bring our girls back campaign. It didn't take long to show her true colours now that the children of Gaza are being killed daily, she has gone into a cave. Shame on you obamas. How do you face your own children or are they also being brainwashed. you just prove that you are a robot being controlled like a puppet. blair was bush's puppet and obama is netanyahooo's puppet. What goes around comes around. sharon became a vegetable, soon netanyahooo will be planted in the vegetable farm. The people of Gaza are THE CHOSEN PEOPLE, they cannot be destroyed. The difference is they have stones in their hands and yet are not afraid to die, whereas the israelis with all their weapons are very afraid to die. Be afraid when you meet GOD, be very afraid. Palestine will live forever and the Palestinians have my respect and admiration. THE CHOSEN PEOPLE.
Trevor Singh 2014-07-31 11:35:43 AM
American Government has a sick sense of humour, you are not happy with Israel but you restock their arms......lol