Share

Court rules ZCC St Engenas' eviction of more than five families unlawful

accreditation
0:00
play article
Subscribers can listen to this article
Judge Jabulani Dhlamini ruled on May 25 that the church should take full responsibility for the settlement of those displaced by the demolition of the house.
Judge Jabulani Dhlamini ruled on May 25 that the church should take full responsibility for the settlement of those displaced by the demolition of the house.
Lucky Nxumalo

NEWS


The St Engenas ZCC church was compelled to seek alternative accommodation and groceries after its church leaders unlawfully evicted people from a building owned by the City of Johannesburg, demolished it and left the occupants destitute.

Consequently, the City of Johannesburg obtained a court order from the Johannesburg High Court this month rendering the decision by church leaders Lesetja Mothiba and Amos Tshabalala to displace more than five families from a municipal building in Alexandra last month as a violation of their constitutional rights.

READ: Church's unhygienic holy war

Judge Jabulani Dhlamini ruled on May 25 that the church should take full responsibility for the settlement of those displaced by the demolition of the house.

According to an affidavit by the City of Johannesburg's director of human settlements, Patrick Phophi, some of the families have been living in the building since 1972.

“The dispute involves a property in the form of a house in Alexandra, which belongs to the applicant, the City of Johannesburg. Historically, it belonged to the Alexandra City Council. The property was initially divided into two and was 154 and 156. The church and the evicted occupiers occupied different rooms and units thereof. These properties have since been merged into one property and it is not known as erf 998 extension 6 Alexandra, Gauteng Province. Both parties have the same rights over the respective units,” read the affidavit.

READ: Unholy war leaves five dead at Modise Church

The City of Johannesburg appointed a task team to deal with the proper allocation of houses within the building.

The papers read:

We were informed that the evictees started with this conduct around February this year, but this was in relation to the other occupiers who did not have permits. In fact, these occupiers occupied a shack, which the respondents allegedly burned down. A spoliation order was sought but removed when the court indicated that there was a material dispute of fact. The application is still pending, and the respondents herein are not parties to it.

The papers list the names of families affected as people relying on the municipality for accommodation.

“When the property was demolished and as there was no prior notice, the evictees’ furniture were scattered and still on the streets of Alexandra. Their food was wasted and some rotten. There is also a video  of the demolition,” read the papers.

READ: Succession battle over Modise's throne heats up

Phophi said that the process embarked on by the church leaders infringed on the constitutional rights of those who were evicted.

A request for comment was sent to the church, who are yet to reply.


We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Join News24 today
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Voting Booth
Peter “Mashata” Mabuse is the latest celebrity to be murdered by criminals. What do you think must be done to stem the tide of serious crime in South Africa?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
Police minister must retire
29% - 84 votes
Murderers deserve life in jail
13% - 38 votes
Bring back the death penalty
57% - 165 votes
Vote